Ask Our Coaches: Reducing Strength Imbalance

Question

About six months ago, I shifted from two-leg to single-leg curls (hamstrings) and extensions (quads) on the machines I use for strength training in my local fitness center two times per week.

I noticed that my left hamstring appeared weaker than my right. I could not complete the 15 reps with a complete curl; after 12-13 reps, I could not pull the weight through the full range of motion. Meanwhile, I was able to complete all 15 reps with the full range of motion using my right leg.

With the extensions, I had no problem completing 15 single leg reps with each leg. Both quads burn an equal amount, and provide the full range of motion.

I began to wonder if the small amount of knee pain I have after running is caused by the imbalance in the strength of my hamstrings. What do you think?

ST

Our Coaches’ Replies

Following is the email string with the response from two coaches.

Coach Kurt Madden

Terry,

Thanks for reaching out to us and sharing this question from an athlete. As I break it down, it appears the athlete has knee pain and left hamstring is weaker than the right hamstring.

Through my career, sometimes the cause of knee pain can be difficult to pinpoint. It could be one issue or several issues. For example,

  • Is this issue discomfort or pain?
  • Where on the knee is the discomfort or pain? Is it below the knee, above the knee, medial, or lateral?
  • Does the athlete run in one pair of shoes or does he/she rotate them?
  • How often does the athlete rotate new running shoes into their running sessions, such as once every two to three months or once every six months?
  • What type of foot strike does the athlete have such as landing on their heel or on their mid-foot?
  • Is the athlete wearing a neutral shoe or stability shoe?
  • What type of surface does the athlete run on?
  • How many sessions does the athlete run each week and what type of sessions do they incorporate such as recovery, tempo, intervals?
  • What type of terrain does the athlete run on such as dirt, grass, asphalt, or treadmill?
  • Can you share any data on running dynamics such as cadence and oscillation?
  • With strength training, does the athlete work on not only strength, but focused on mobility and stretching too?
  • With strength training, does the athlete understand and implement periodization to focus on stability, mobility, strength, and power or do the same workouts in most sessions?
  • How much time does the spending on foam rolling, massage, or doing yoga?
  • How durable is the athlete relative to being able to handle the stress and intensity of running?
  • What is the height and weight of the athlete and how long have they been actively running?
  • Is the athlete applying ice, CBD cream, or Tiger Balm to the knee following run session?
  • Has the athlete had a professional chiropractor with an applied kinesiology approach review the alignment of the spine, leg length, and assess the organs that are aligned the areas around the knee?

As you can see, there are several factors that can contribute to knee discomfort or knee pain. Additionally, through my tenure as a coach and athlete, I have learned that typically more miles of running or higher volume at Zone 2 will weaken your hamstrings.

Hopefully, the information I have shared will be helpful.

Regards,

Kurt Madden

Email: kurt.madden@tridot.com

Sign-Up Link: https://app.tridot.com/onboard/sign-up/kurtmadden

Coach Tony Washington

Like Kurt outlined, knee pain and the observation of an imbalance of left and right hamstring strength is hard to diagnose.

I’ve had athletes do single-sided exercises with adding one rep per set on the weak until the strength is more balanced. Barring other issues (structural, injury caused, scarring, etc) this has helped my folks even up their imbalance.

Yoga and other foundation regimens are great at overall mobility, stability, movement, strength, and force improvements. [I have seen] recent success with Erin Carson’s Mobility Monday on YouTube and her subscribed plans.

Hope this helps,

Tony Washington

Email: tony.washington@tridot.com

Sign-Up Link: https://app.tridot.com/onboard/sign-up/tonywashington

What Has Worked For You?

What have you found to be effective in reducing strength imbalance? Share your experience, or questions in the Comments below.

Comments: Please note that I review all comments before they are posted. You will be notified by email when your comment is approved. Even if you do not submit a comment, you may subscribe to be notified when a comment is published.

Have a Question For Our Coaches?

Send your question to Our Coaches here.

How To Slow Age-Related Drop in Running Performance

We often expect some drop in running speed as we age. Still, how can we minimize it? This post is based on TriDot coach Kurt Madden’s response to a request from a senior triathlete in his late 60s who hopes to reverse a dramatic drop in his running performance.

How Can I Reverse a Drop in Running Performance?

David, one of our community of senior triathletes, sent me the following request.

“I’m looking for some articles and guidance on nutrition for senior triathletes. I’m going to be 69 in July and my endurance has dropped dramatically in the past 4 years. The run has been the most affected. I expect age related drops but have gone from an 8:45 [minute per mile] pace to an 11:45 [minute per mile] pace on the run after bike.”

I sent David’s request to Our Coaches, and asked them to share the most common causes for drops in performance they see among older athletes. Kurt Madden, a TriDot Certified Coach and Head of Coach Development for TriDot, offered to speak with me about what he sees. Kurt’s comments are the basis for the rest of this post.

Protein-Based Diet

According to Coach Madden, David is correct in asking about nutrition when wanting to recover his earlier running performance.

To begin with, any person in training should be “building their nutritional regimen around protein”. This can include lean protein and any combination of protein-containing foods that provide all essential amino acids. Such a diet can slow aging somewhat. How?

Kurt said, “Fifty percent of the cellular membrane is protein. Generally speaking, for males and for females, as we look at current data, any person who is active, including seniors, should strive for close to one gram of protein per pound of body weight.” This is equivalent to 2.2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight, higher than general recommendations for older active adults.

A common mistake of athletes in training is, according to Kurt, “protein fasting”. Protein fasting occurs when the athlete does not consume the recommended amount of protein. It also occurs when protein is not consumed throughout the day. We can’t starve ourselves of protein for sixteen hours, then cram it in at the end of the day. This is because it takes time for our bodies to absorb the protein we consume.

According to an article titled The Science Behind Intermittent Fasting For Athletes, “Your protein absorption rate may be as low as 8-10 grams per hour. Intermittent fasting limits one’s ability to spread protein intake throughout the day. This may not be a problem if your protein needs fit effectively within an 8-hour eating window. But if you have extremely high protein needs (say, you’re training for a triathlon and spend 3+ hours/day training) you may need to supplement with protein even during a fasting period.”

What About Intermittent Fasting?

I asked Kurt about intermittent fasting, considering this advice. From his response, I learned that while intermittent fasting may help with weight loss, the athlete in training who employs this approach may give up the quality of cellular development and quality of their metabolism. “If we can build in protein throughout the day, our waking hours, we are going to help build the cell membranes and help with recovery. To me, that is a huge win right there.”

Not absorbing enough protein while in training is, according to Coach Madden, “like a battery pack on a flashlight. You’ve got four batteries in there, but only two are working.”

Kurt continued, “The power house of the cell, that is the mitochondria. When everything within the cell is fed, it is going to produce at a much higher level. They can get larger, they can increase in size and number at any age. That’s the importance when you look at protein.”

Athletes who do not absorb enough protein will “struggle with recovery and doing powerful things, like trying to maintain your running speed at any age, versus people that are not [protein fasting] who recover quicker, generally speaking, and not going to see that rapid decline [in running speed]. So, just that tweak there is going to be incredible.”

Twenty Different Vegetables and Fruits Each Week

In addition, Kurt said, “It’s really important to try to get twenty different fruits and vegetables every single week with a shift toward more vegetables than fruits.” While fruits provide antioxidants, they also contain more sugar than vegetables.

Kurt emphasizes the need to “be strategic in your carbohydrate intake. Ideally you are getting complex carbohydrates versus simple sugars. And you are doing it strategically so every day in your training you know that if you are training less than an hour, you don’t need a surplus of carbohydrates. Conversely, if you are in a longer session any day of the week, if it’s a two hour bike ride and a thirty-minute run, you definitely need to shift those carbohydrates over.”

How Clean Are You Eating?

“And then the thing that I find with people who struggle a little with their weight, when I see a ratio of protein to carbohydrates, it’s not one to one or it’s not one to two. It’s like one for protein and four for carbohydrates. And many times what goes into that mix, when you really peel the onion back, is that their percentage of processed foods is much larger. Processed food will slow down your recovery.”

Following these guidelines will slow age-related performance decline for everyone, including seniors.

Related post: What Masters Athletes Need To Know About Nutrition

Building Strength and Endurance Reverses a Drop in Running Performance

Another area in which we can affect age-related performance is training. Kurt began this part of our discussion by referring to a May 14, 2024 article in Triathlete magazine titled How Much Slower Will You Get As You “Age Up” in Triathlon?. This article documents slower Ironman 70.3 run times that begin in our late 20s or early 30s and progress with age.

While the article mentions five main reasons for age-related performance declines, Kurt identified two of these for seniors to target in their training: (1) strength and (2) oxygen uptake.

“When you look at your oxygen uptake, the amount of oxygen that you can deliver to the working muscles . . . you are going to see that decline [with age]. That’s unavoidable because you are losing your strength.”

For this reason, seniors must include strength training, being careful to avoid injury. “Accept that by doing strength training, you are putting some stress on your ligaments, your tendons, your long bones, your connective tissue.” Still, he reminds seniors to remember that they are no longer in your 20s. Start slow.

Getting Uncomfortable to Get Faster

Still, beyond reduced strength, another cause for reduced oxygen uptake is our approach to training. “Typically, what we see, when you look at research, is that when people get older, they are more comfortable staying in a Zone 2, aerobic type training program. They are exercising. Hallelujah. I think that is beyond awesome. However, most people who are seniors, they are not willing to get uncomfortable. They are not doing the high intensity training.”

“It’s kind of like investing. How can I get bigger gains in my investments, and still be ethical and honest? Zone 2 is like investing in bonds. You’re not going to lose a thing. That’s awesome. If you want to be a little more ambitious, you’ve got to raise that bar again and, as we say, get into anerobic or you get things at your anerobic threshold. That is a true separation. And we see that.

“I can look at article after article about people in their sixties and seventies. It’s scary. People are running under three hour marathons. I was looking at results just last weekend for an Ironman 70.3 over on the east coast. A person that did a 70.3, they did a 1.2 mile swim, they did a 56 mile bike ride, and they ran a half marathon. They ran eight minute miles at age 65 to 69.

Add Some Good Stress

“I have to believe it could be two things. Number one, genetically, they are just flat out superior. But, secondly, I have to believe that person is doing some high intensity training because you have to stimulate your cardiovascular system. You have to put a little bit of stress on it and know you also need to back off.

“And that’s the beauty of TriDot. I work with 80 year olds, 70 year olds, 60 year olds, 50 year olds. I’m 68. I know later today, I have a session on a bike for an hour and I have got to get twenty-one minutes at Zone 4. And I know that I am going to get bigger gains or be able to maintain my oxygen uptake when I do that.

“Same thing on the run and the swim. But when we go to David’s question about the run, that’s very typical. We ask, well why does that happen? Well, I think to be very candid, running is the most stressful of all three disciplines. Because, you’ve got gravity. You’ve got force. You’ve got this person pounding on their ligaments, tendons, musculature, and connective tissue. And we see most injuries happening through running. And many times, it’s the volume of running, it’s overuse of running.

Balancing and Optimizing Stress

“And, again, when you see that decline, mostly speaking, I have to look at this person’s training program. They need to run at Zone 4 and Zone 3, not excessively, but have something that is optimizing them. Why? Because again, your body is going to get used to performing at that level. That prevents the decline they are going to see.

Kurt continued, “In swimming . . as long as your range of motion is good, you have the buoyancy factor. On the bike, you’re not pounding. If you’re disciplined, have good strength, good balance, mental toughness, you can hang on.”

“I just know, I did a max VO2 on the bike two weeks ago. It was close to what I did thirty years ago.”

Rest & Recovery For Better Running Performance

“Every person is a little different in the rest and recovery they need.

“Many times when we see [an athlete’s] performance declining, we get right to sleep factor. Shut things off so they are no longer getting blue light coming off screens fifteen hours a day. They shut things off and get the quality of sleep and recovery.”

Related post: Rest and Recovery: Why It’s Important for Senior Triathletes

Running Performance: A Three-Legged Stool

Just as a three-legged stool or tripod is the most stable platform, so is a training approach that considers the three principal contributors to running performance. Whether training for running or the triathlon run, a comprehensive plan will address these three legs:

  • Nutrition
  • Training
  • Rest

Of the three sports of triathlon, running is the one most sensitive to proper balance of these.

Need Your Own Plan?

Do you want a review of your current training plan or a plan tailored to you? Contact Kurt or one of Our Coaches.

Comments: Please note that I review all comments before they are posted. You will be notified by email when your comment is approved. Even if you do not submit a comment, you may subscribe to be notified when a comment is published.

Other Contributions By Coach Madden

Since our affiliation with TriDot began nearly a year and a half ago, Kurt Madden has helped on several Senior Triathletes posts. He is the exclusive contributor to these two:

Leveraging TriDot to Optimize Your Training at Any Age

How To Make Triathlon Training Senior-Specific

Kurt has also regularly responded to questions raised by readers in the Ask Our Coaches series.

Ask Our Coaches: Training For A Sprint Triathlon In The Final Six Weeks

Question

A 69-year old member of our community who had done 13 sprint triathlons in the past three years is seeking Our Coaches’ advice. In particular, he asked for advice on training for a sprint triathlon that is six weeks from now. He indicated he is not fast and often finishes near the end, so I assume his main goal is to finish this triathlon.

Our Coaches’ Replies

Following is the email string with the response from two two coaches.

Coach Kurt Madden

Congratulations on competing in these events, and as you prepare for your next event in approximately six weeks, you might want to consider the following:

  • Maintain your consistency with your training and I would suggest that you train in the range of five days a week. Sessions should be a variety of recovery and higher threshold sessions.
  • Do your best to have two training sessions before the race where you are doing some type of race simulation. Ideally, it would be four weeks and two weeks before your race. During your race rehearsals, focus on your pacing, transitions, and nutrition. Furthermore, do your best to simulate the actual race course during your race simulation.
  • Make sure all of your equipment that you will be using on race day is ready to go within two weeks of the race to make sure you are not rushing or scrambling just before the race.

In closing, as you continue to be active in the sport of triathlons, you should strongly consider using some level of subscription on TriDot. It will provide you will a customized, personalized, and optimized training program to get you race ready as well as help prevent injuries.

You can use this link to learn more about TriDot:

https://www.tridot.com/?gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAjw5v2wBhBrEiwAXDDoJTo4fAnY60xT0pSfBTG4KtoUmFZ-iXaYNl2XG2y3msyEgKZYjzvDPhoCmY0QAvD_BwE

Regards,

Kurt Madden

Email: kurt.madden@tridot.com

Coach Tony Washington

Thanks Terry and Kurt.

It’s always hard to add to Kurt. I’d also consider some mobility and stability workouts. Yoga is great to keep us all ready for the next workout and race. After the 6 week build to this race, add some strength work.

Rest, recovery and great nutrition will keep you training and racing for many years to come.

Cheers,

Tony Washington

Email: tony.washington@tridot.com

Have a Question For Our Coaches?

Send your question to Our Coaches here.

Ask Our Coaches: Comfortably Biking Longer Distance

Question

I have been considering longer distance triathlon or aquabike races. However, the saddle on my bike leaves my bottom numb after 10 miles. I am not comfortable riding more than about 15 miles in this condition. What do you recommend? Is there a different type or brand of bike saddle I should use? Are there other things I can do to comfortably ride 50 or even 100 miles?

Terry V.

Our Coaches’ Replies

Following is the email string in which three coaches answered the question.

Coach Tony Washington

Terry,

Saddle soreness can have multiple causes. Bike fit is a good place to start. Especially since anything over 10 miles is painful. Fore/Aft, tilt and height are important in how your sit bones interact with the bike. One of my athletes tried 5 different (all borrowed) saddles. After she had a proper bike fit, it turned out her original saddle was perfect. Shorter crank length helped with a more open hip angle. Been on the same saddle for 4 years now.

My saddle recommendations vary depending on bike type. On a triathlon or TT bike, I like a split nose saddle like the ISM Adamo or Bisaddle. Rolling your hips forward when you are in the aero position on the bike puts pressure in a different spot on your pelvis. These noseless saddles are better suited for most athletes.

On a road bike, it can be very subjective. The nicer seats have a cutout that encourages normal blood flow to keep you pain and numbness free. If you have a good relationship with your local bike shop, they often have loaner saddles to mount and try for a few rides. I’ve personally had great luck with Selle Italia. I have used them since 1982.

Good trunk stability/mobility/strength can aid in being comfortable for a long ride. Strong and stable hips with a smooth pedal stroke balancing your quads, hamstrings and glutes is key here. Higher cadence (above 80) enhances pedal smoothness and can help with pain.

Hope this helps,

Cheers,

Tony

Email: tony.washington@tridot.com

Coach Jenn Reinhart

That is a great answer Tony and not much I could add to it. Bike fit is definitely the place to start. Good bike fitters can usually offer suggestions for a saddle based on your fit too.

Being that uncomfortable so quickly definitely should not be the norm. At times, even with the best fit and saddle, a change in shorts (depending on if you ride in cycling or tri shorts), can cause some chaffing, but not the degree of discomfort you are describing.

Jenn Reinhart 

Email: jenn.reinhart@tridot.com

Coach Kurt Madden

Terry,

I echo everything that Tony has shared and learned that a new saddle takes at least six weeks to break in and feel comfortable. Over the past 10 years, my two most favorite and most comfortable saddles are the. Adamo and ISM 3.0

Regards,

Kurt Madden

Email: kurt.madden@tridot.com

Coach Tony Washington (follow-up reply)

To add to what Jenn mentioned about shorts, bib shorts can lift and hold everything in place better than shorts with a drawstring when leaned over in the aero position.

To add to Kurt’s comments, ISM has several models of different lengths, widths and padding thickness. A fitter can help with making a choice.

Cheers,

Tony

Email: tony.washington@tridot.com

Have a Question For Our Coaches?

Send your question to Our Coaches here.

error

Enjoy this post? Please spread the word :)